Pentagon Federal 5-Year, 7-Years CD Rates at 3.04% APY

Pentagon Federal Credit Union officially announced some competitive new rates for their money market certificates (basically CDs, or certificates of deposit) starting December 1st, 2013. The minimum opening deposit is $1,000.

Term APY Early Withdrawal Penalty*
(days of interest)
2-Year CD 1.41% Last 180 days
3-Year CD 2.02% Last 180 days
4-Year CD 2.22% Last 180 days
5-Year CD 3.04% Last 365 days
7-Year CD 3.04% Last 365 days

Here is an interesting chart comparing the effective APY depending on holding period (taking into account the early withdrawal penalty) for the 4-year and 5-year CDs. We see that the 5-year CD (and 7-year CD) actually matches the 3-year CD held to maturity at the 3-year mark (both 2.02%) and is slightly better than the 4-year CD held to maturity at the 4-year mark (2.28% vs 2.22%). However, for some interim time periods (7 to 28 months) the shorter penalty will make the effective yield of the 4-year CD higher.

The 7-year CD looks essentially like the 5-year curve except the spike moves farther out and it keeps going up for the 6th and 7th years. If you held the 5-year until the very end and withdrew a month early, you’d end up with only 2.42% APY. With the 7-year, it would be 2.60%.

Although future interest rates are unknown, I would say that the 4-year and 5-year CD are the best deals. The 4-year is good because even if you held only for one year, you’d get an effective 1.11% APY better than most 1-year CDs. The 5-year is better for those with longer time horizons, as shown by the curve. The 7-year is for those who don’t think rates will get any better and want to lock in that 3%+ as long as possible. These rates are not guaranteed for any length of time, so I’d open a CD immediately if I was interested.

If you opened a 3-year CD recently when they announced the 2.02% APY rate, keep in mind you can close it and only lose any accumulated interest; the original deposit amount is unaffected. Hat tip to DepositAccounts for breaking the news of rumored rates ahead of time.

Details on early withdrawal penalties:

  • For terms from 6 months to 4 years, you will lose the last 180 days of interest. If you haven’t earned 180 days of interest yet, you lose all the interest and get back only your opening amount.
  • For terms of 5 years or longer, you will lose the last 365 days of interest. If you haven’t earned 365 days of interest yet, you lose all the interest and get back only your opening amount.

As a credit union, you must meet their eligibility requirements to join. Basically all members of the military and their immediate families are welcome, as well as many other military-related groups. Otherwise, anyone can become a member of the organization Voices for America’s Troops. Membership costs $15/yr, and you don’t need to renew to remain a PenFed member. “Voices for America’s Troops advocates for a strong national defense, including sustaining and improving quality of life programs for America’s troops, their families and survivors.”

Comments

  1. At what point/amount do these rates become favorable over Ally GICs, assuming you have to pay $15 to become a member?

  2. @Canuck – The Ally 5-year CD is much lower at 1.60% or so, and the super-short early withdrawal penalty ends really soon on December 7th. If you did buy before then, there would be a small window where the Ally CD would outperform between the 2-month to 1-year period roughly.

    This is all neglecting the $15 fee, as that is dependent on CD size. PenFed has a pretty good history of good rates from time to time that I think being able to join for $15 is a great deal and may not last forever (it may be much harder to join in the future, but if you join now you are forever a member).

  3. These rates are extraordinary. This either means Penfed strongly believes interest rates to rise fast and soon. Or that it has dug itself into a financial hole and is desperately trying to attract new deposits. I hope it’s the former because I just bought couple of 5 year CDs.

    I didn’t understand your comment about Ally bank CDs. Are they changing their policy of 60 day penalty for early withdrawal?

  4. @whytax – It is interesting considering their own 5/5 ARM mortgage product has a rate of 2.625% for the first 5 years. But this is not the first time they’ve offered this high on relative basis.

    See previous post regarding Ally CD penalty changes:

    http://www.mymoneyblog.com/all.....hange.html

  5. Thanks. Nice to know Ally is not changing terms retroactively. Penfed, which is governed by a rather toothless NCUA, might change the rules retroactively though.

  6. Also you can become PenFed member if you are a Red Cross volunteer, which they define to include donors (of money and blood). I think I read that on this blog in the past. I donate blood semi-regularly so the way I read it that makes me eligible to be a member without any recurring monetary fee:
    https://www.penfed.org/RedCross/

    In fact, there is a box on their membership form:
    https://www.penfed.org/13/?

  7. Not sure if this has been mentioned before about Penfed, but they currently only allow you to transfer OUT of Penfed $5k per day. You can transfer in more than that. Now that one of my CD’s has matured, it will take a few days to get the money out. Good to know if you think you’ll be in a rush….

  8. It gets better: can’t make more than 1 outbound transfers within a 3 day window! Got this as I tried to move out a 2nd chunk of money: “PRESENTLY, PENFED PROHIBITS THE EXECUTION OF MORE THAN ONE OUTBOUND ELECTRONIC (ACH) TRANSACTION TO AN OUTSIDE FINANCIAL INSTITUTION WITHIN THREE BUSINESS DAYS (SUNDAY IS PENFED’S ONLY NON-BUSINESS DAY) PER ACCOUNT. OUR RECORDS INDICATE THAT THIS LIMIT HAS ALREADY BEEN REACHED. YOU WILL BE PERMITTED TO INITIATE YOUR TRANSACTION ON THE FOURTH BUSINESS DAY ONCE THE WAITING PERIOD RESETS. PLEASE CONTACT PENFED IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS. (50538)”.

  9. It’s not as convenient, but you should be able to request a check for the full amount, have it mailed to your address, and then deposit it in your other account. That was what I did when I withdrew my CD. (minus the 5 dollars that has to stay in the regular share account)

Speak Your Mind

*