Here’s another post on the topic of creating good habits…
A common investing question is whether it is better to invest your money all at once (lump-sum) or gradually over time (dollar-cost averaging). The standard answer is that lump-sum is generally a better choice than dollar-cost averaging. This is mostly simple mathematics; If something goes up on average, then you’ll want your money in as early as possible.
However, in this Financial Planning magazine article Does investing monthly or annually beat a lump-sum portfolio? by Craig L. Israelsen, he argues that in the real world the best solution is regular, monthly investing. I recommend reading the original piece, but here is how I mentally broke down the concept:
- The most important thing to building wealth is saving a lot of money (savings rate).
- The best way to save a lot is to save often over time.
- The best way to save often is to develop a regular habit of it, so that it becomes effortless over the years.
- The hardest part about developing a habit is at the very beginning. You need an initial streak that is uninterrupted.
- The most likely thing to interrupt your streak is seeing a big drop when you look at your monthly account statements. That is scary. As humans, we like to focus on that number.
- With lump-sum contributions, you are much more likely to see a drop on a month-to-month basis. You have committed your money, and it is now subject to the market’s whims. You are also given a lot of time to think between actions, and you’ll have to muster up the motivation to make another lump-sum investment later.
- With regular, monthly contributions and a small portfolio size, you will hardly ever see an account balance drop.
Historical data from 1980-2015. Consider a diversified portfolio of stocks and bonds (details in the article). The following chart has three columns that compare overall market returns, an annual investment of $3,600 made each year on January 1st, and a monthly investment of $300 made at the start of each month.
In the beginning, your account balance “feels” like it is always growing, even though the market itself may be flat or even dropping. This is the benefit of regular, monthly contributions. The positive reinforcement will hopefully let an investing habit form. As your portfolio gets bigger, the difference between dollar-cost averaging and lump-sum investing becomes relatively insignificant.
Bottom line. Building the habit is the most important thing. If at all possible, you should make automatic, monthly investments. When your account is small, systematic investments make it more likely that the number on your monthly statement keeps rising every month. By the time that your portfolio starts to get big enough that it doesn’t help anymore, you’ll have already built the habit and be on the path to solid wealth. By the way, if you invest as soon as you have the money available (i.e. when you get your paycheck) then you already are getting your money in the market as soon as possible.